Resources
Blog

How to Stop Alarm Fatigue from Killing Your Predictive Maintenance Program

Contents

See MaintainX in action

Take a live, one-on-one tour with a product expert to see how MaintainX can help you.
Book a Tour

You see an alarm on the Line 3 HMI saying that the gearbox motor is drawing higher-than-normal current. But this is the fourth time in the last six weeks you’ve seen this alarm, and each time you’ve checked the gearbox, it’s been running fine. 

But not this time. 

The motor fails two days later, leading to a catastrophic breakdown and hours of lost production.

This kind of alert fatigue, where maintenance and operations teams receive so many false alarms that they eventually get ignored en masse, is one of the most common threats to condition-based and predictive maintenance (PdM) strategies. Creating a predictive maintenance workflow you can trust is what determines if your PdM program leads to fewer breakdowns and less downtime. 

This guide covers practical strategies that your reliability team can use to set up thresholds and alarms you can trust so you can stop alarm fatigue from killing your predictive maintenance program.

Why predictive maintenance alerts get ignored

Maintenance teams can invest huge chunks of their budget and weeks (if not months) setting up predictive maintenance technology on their assets, only to ignore what these systems tell them. An alert flashes across a screen and it’s met with immediate skepticism, or outright denial, every single time. The problem usually comes down to trust.

Ryan McBride, a Manufacturing Reliability Manager at Schreiber Foods, puts it simply: technicians want to "get every penny out of that [asset]." When a PdM system flags a component for repair or replacement while the equipment is still running, taking any action feels wasteful. The proof isn’t strong enough to change the habits of the team.

Several factors drive alert fatigue and dismissal:

  • The "still running" mindset: Frontline teams associate failure with catastrophic breakdown, not the early-stage degradation that PdM detects
  • Perceived waste: Replacing a functioning component seems financially irresponsible
  • Technology skepticism: If people can’t see how technology arrives at an answer, like a recommendation to replace a part, the entire system is invalidated
  • Vague recommendations: When teams get non-specific alerts, they don’t have enough details to plan and act

The gap between what technicians often see as failure and what predictive maintenance identifies as failure creates a fundamental disconnect. Traditional failure means equipment stops with obvious symptoms and consequences. PdM-detected failure means early degradation caught while the asset still operates normally.

10 ways to create predictive maintenance alerts that catch failure and avoid alarm fatigue

The crying wolf problem undermines even the best predictive maintenance programs. When teams receive more alerts than they can act on, they start ignoring all of them, including the critical ones. Here are 10 ways to create a predictive maintenance program that you can rely on, instead of just making more noise for your team to filter out.

1. Start small and in the places you have the most confidence in

The biggest mistake is putting a sensor on as many assets and components as you can. Predictive maintenance only works when you know a failure mode can be detected early and with enough confidence that the team can act on it before it has an impact on your operation. That might mean starting with a single line and catching five failures a year, but preventing each failure will have a big impact on production and costs.

Prioritize one to five critical assets where failure hurts production, safety, or the budget. Prove the process works on a small set, then expand.

2. Assign an owner and action to every alert

If an alert doesn’t map to a specific person and a specific response, it shouldn’t exist. Before you turn any alarm on, answer three questions: 

  1. Who sees it and how? 
  2. What do they do when they see the alert? 
  3. What is the expected response time? 

If you can’t answer those, the alarm is just noise with a timestamp. Link alerts directly to work orders or inspection tasks so the response is built into the workflow, not left to someone’s judgment at 3 a.m.

3. Get baselines before you set thresholds.

Don’t rely only on the thresholds outlined by OEMs or past estimates. Monitor the performance of assets and components for a few weeks, even using sensors to simply capture data first. Cross-reference this with the condition, operating context, and maintenance of the asset during this period. Ideally, the machine will run across different loads, shifts, products, and operating contexts so you can understand how changing these variables alters the performance and condition of equipment. Set thresholds based on that asset’s actual normal behavior, then tighten them over time.

4. Use a combination of signals to assess and route alerts

If you respond to every single anomaly picked up by a sensor, it’s easy to get tricked by a spike caused by something as innocuous as a forklift driving by. Set alarms to only sound when there is a sustained pattern of anomalous activity over several readings, such as ‘vibration outside of thresholds five times in 10 minutes.’ Also look for a correlation across multiple parameters before escalating, such as a rise in vibration and temperature.

Even when you get an alert, stop to consider if there is anything else affecting the asset, like startups, shutdowns, changeovers, cleaning cycles, or increased production. If vibration levels are anomalous and you can also see that production is heavier than normal, it’s probably worth looking into.

Lastly, don’t treat every alert the same. Break it into one of three categories:

  • Advisory: Trending in the wrong direction. It goes into a daily or weekly review, no interruption.
  • Warning: Needs a planned inspection or work order within days.
  • Critical: Act now. This is the only level that should wake someone up.

Ryan's team uses criticality assessments to determine which assets warrant monitoring and urgent response. He scores assets based on production impact, safety implications, and redundancy.

5. Remove emotional bias from criticality assessments

Ryan describes what he calls "emotional criticality," which is the tendency to over-prioritize equipment that causes headaches rather than equipment with the highest business impact.

For example, he noticed that a forklift was assigned a surprisingly high criticality score. When the team discussed it, they realized another forklift could cover if the first one failed. The emotional frustration with that particular asset had inflated its perceived criticality.

Challenge assumptions when scoring seems off. Ask "what would happen if this failed?" to test true criticality. Involve multiple perspectives, including maintenance, production, and engineering, to balance viewpoints.

6. Use secondary methods to validate alerts

Ryan recommends checking predictions using other methods for detecting anomalies in equipment. For example, if vibration analysis flags a bearing that’s going to fail, confirm with infrared thermography or acoustic monitoring before putting resources behind a fix that stops production.

"If that recommendation came from a vibration technology, now we can go out with infrared and thermography and validate that recommendation," Ryan explains. The alert is what triggers an investigation that ends in a human making a final decision, rather than relying solely on technology and blaming it when it’s wrong.

7. Show proof that failures are real

One strategy that helped Ryan and the reliability team at Schreiber Foods trust their alerts was conducting tear downs of failing components flagged by the predictive maintenance system. For example, after bearings were flagged for replacement, the team opened up the old components to see first-hand the damage on rolling elements and races.

Physical evidence proved far more persuasive than any report. Technicians could see the early stages of failure despite the fact that the machine was still running. “That gave [technicians] a lot of understanding of the alerts, but also a lot of buy-in to the strategy.”

Geraldo Signorini, a Principal Industry Manager at MaintainX who spent years working in reliability in the oil and gas industry, says that he often kept a "trophy room" where his team saved all broken and destroyed pieces. It was a reminder of the tactics that worked and the lessons they learned.

8. Review alarms on a regular basis and kill the ones that don’t earn their place.

Measure the percentage of alerts that led to a real finding, then review the alarms that led to false positives or were ignored most. For each one, ask: should we fix the threshold, add a condition, or kill it? 

Make this a standing meeting, not a one-time cleanup, because thresholds drift as equipment ages and processes change. If an alarm has fired repeatedly with no action taken, delete it or fix it. An ignored alarm is worse than no alarm because it trains people to ignore the next one.

9. Create a feedback loop between planners and technicians

The communication gap between planners creating jobs and technicians executing them affects both job quality and data quality. Closing this loop improves the entire predictive maintenance program.

Ryan emphasizes that planners shouldn't expect perfection on the first attempt. Instead, technicians provide feedback after completing jobs to improve future plans.

"Rather than say check belt tension, we said the belt tension should be X plus or minus Y, and then we have a field that they input what that belt tension was," Ryan explains. 

When teams see their data being used to improve procedures and catch problems, they're more motivated to enter quality information.

10. Share wins and be transparent about the gaps

When you get an alert but other priorities take precedence, communicate that decision clearly. Don’t just say the system failed, the predictive technology failed, or the maintenance group failed. Explain it instead. 

“You can say ‘We looked at that criticality and did the risk assessment, but these other things took greater priority, and it’s still a win because we knew about it,’” says Ryan. 

Even when the predicted failure does happen, the alert still has value. Ryan’s team had cases where they couldn’t act in time but had already ordered parts and prepared resources, so, “When it did fail, we were able to get it back up and running a lot quicker because of those preparations.”

How MaintainX helps teams act on predictive maintenance alerts

The gap between receiving an alert and completing a repair is where many PdM programs break down. Mobile-first work order creation helps teams respond faster to alerts, while real-time communication keeps planners and technicians aligned on priorities.

Digital procedures with specific data fields capture quality information that improves the program. Work history provides the evidence trail for recording catches and showing program ROI to leadership.

Sign Up For Free

author photo

Marc Cousineau is the Senior Content Marketing Manager at MaintainX. Marc has over a decade of experience telling stories for technology brands, including more than five years writing about the maintenance and asset management industry.

Learn more

View related procedures to improve your maintenance operations

No items found.
“MaintainX is innovative and nimble. They provide an intuitive solution to help take your reliability program to the next level.”
See MaintainX in action
Fields marked with an asterisk (*) are required.

Fields marked with an asterisk (*) are required.

By submitting the form, you acknowledge our Privacy Policy.

By submitting the form, you acknowledge our Privacy Policy.
Thank you
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.